Sunday, March 18, 2018

When Does Painting a Portrait Violate the Subject’s Rights?





Art Market
When Does Painting a Portrait Violate the Subject’s Rights?
The Allegory of Painting
Johannes Vermeer
Museum of Fine Art, Vienna
It might be hard to remember now, but there was a time when Tiger Woods was the highest-paid athlete in the world. Ah, the mid-2000s. In his prime, the golfer appeared in advertisements for American Express, Nike, and Buick, among other companies that paid good money to associate his persona with their brand.
But when painter Rick Rush depicted Woods (including his iconic red shirt) in a 1998 artwork titled The Masters of Augusta, he didn’t think he needed to pay the golfer to paint his portrait. Woods felt otherwise—to him, Rush’s so-called “artwork” was glorified commercial sports memorabilia. He sued, alleging that the artist, who put thousands of copies of his piece up for sale online, commercialized Woods’s image without permission or payment, violating what is known as the right of publicity.
The Woods lawsuit raised an aspect of publicity rights litigation that courts often wrestle with: What is the line between art and commerce? It is an important question, given that art enjoys broader free speech protections than the latter. It’s unlikely a Nike TV spot can successfully claim to be art—but what about a painting with limited edition prints sold through a website? When does that line get crossed?
Laws regarding the right of publicity vary from state to state, but generally they allow people to have commercial control over their persona and likeness. The logic is simple enough: Only you should get to profit from your image, and others shouldn’t be able to use it for economic gain without your permission. There are exceptions, notably instances in which the use of an image is in the public interest, such as in a newspaper.
The limits to publicity rights have been repeatedly tested by artists, who assert that constitutional free speech protections guaranteed under the First Amendment trump an individual’s right to control the use of her or his likeness by someone else.
“You have the First Amendment colliding with a purely personal right,” said Christine Steiner, a California-based attorney who has written on this issue. “And typically the First Amendment will prevail.”
In the case of Tiger Woods, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Rush, finding that his work depicted a historic event of cultural value (Woods winning the Masters) and did not “propose a commercial transaction.” Moreover, Rush had significantly transformed Woods’s likeness for his work, with the painting constituting “expression which is entitled to the full protection of the First Amendment.” Today, you can still buy a print online.
Broadly, courts have favored artists in this and similar cases, as long as they refrain from mass-producing the image too widely on commercial goods. “There is a limited right to use someone’s likeness in a ‘fine art’ context, perhaps without their permission,” said Joshua J. Kaufman, head of Venable’s Copyright and Licensing group. “I would steer them away from licensing the artwork—be it on puzzles, keychains, posters, any of those types of uses.”
A major example of a court ruling against an artist came in April 2001, when California’s Supreme Court ruled against artist Gary Saderup, who sold his drawing of the Three Stooges on t-shirts and as lithograph prints. His depiction of Larry, Curly, and Moe violated their rights of publicity—held by a corporate entity even after the Stooges died—not because it appeared on a t-shirt rather than a canvas, but because it was a “a literal, conventional” image that commercially exploited the likeness of the comedians without any creative additions, the Los Angeles Times reported. The court found that “depictions of celebrities amounting to little more than the appropriation of the celebrity’s economic value are not protected expression under the First Amendment.”
The court stepped into the role of art critic, directly comparing Saderup to artists who’ve also used celebrity imagery in their work, like Andy Warhol. Unlike Saderup, Warhol would be safe from a right of publicity lawsuit because his work “went beyond the commercial exploitation of celebrity images and became a form of ironic social comment on the dehumanization of celebrity itself,” according to the judgment.
Because the right of publicity is a state right, different courts will have differing opinions over what constitutes an exception, or who is even entitled to the right. In California, an element of transformation is important. And in that state, even the dead, like the Three Stooges, have a right of publicity that lasts 70 years after dying. Other states have taken different approaches. In Tennessee, the right of publicity law lasts for perpetuity (legislators actually crafted the law for Tennessee native Elvis Presley).
In other states, however, such as New York, the right of publicity holds only during the lifetime of a person. A 1993 case shows the extent to which New York courts have been reticent to curtail artistic freedoms—even when the artist is casting a likeness of a person for a sculpture. Supermodel Cheryl Tiegs entered into a messy legal fight with sculptor Mihail Simeonov over a plaster cast the artist had made of Tiegs with her consent. He planned on selling sculptures he created using this cast, but the supermodel said she never would give permission to the sculptor to sell her image. (Tiegs had agreed to the cast to show that it was not a harmful process and could be used on elephants as part of a wildlife preservation awareness campaign.)
But a New York court found the sculptor’s use didn’t qualify as trade or an advertisement and that his rights under the first amendment exceeded Tiegs’s right to control her image, even though the Tiegs sculpture would quite literally have been cast from the supermodel’s body. “An artist may make a work of art that includes a recognizable likeness of a person without her or his written consent and sell at least a limited number of copies thereof without violating” his or her right of publicity, the court found.
So if you’re not Tiger Woods or Elvis or a supermodel, should you care? Yes, because even the regular, non-famous Jane Q. Public has the right to prevent the use of her likeness for another’s commercial gain. So Coke can’t take your picture while you’re sipping a soda on the sidewalk and slap your face on an advertisement as part of a huge marketing campaign (at least not without permission). But can an artist?
This was the question at the heart of a famous 2005 case involving a private citizen whose photo was taken by Philip-Lorca DiCorcia for his series “Heads.” The photographer snapped photos of unaware New Yorkers walking in Time Square using sophisticated lighting techniques to create stylized portraits. The photographer created 10 prints and three artist’s proofs of each photograph, selling the prints for figures between $20,000 and $30,000 apiece (roughly between $30,000 and $45,000 today).
One subject, Erno Nussenzweig, who was also an Orthodox Jew, was none too happy about his close up. Nussenzweig sued DiCorcia, charging the photograph violated his religious rights, as well as his privacy rights, because it was taken without permission. Nussenzweig argued the photograph wasn’t a work of art entitled to broad First Amendment protections, but rather a commercial object for sale through a commercial gallery.
“The problem of sorting out what may or may not legally be ‘art’ remains a difficult one,” opined the court. But ultimately, it easily found that the photographs did constitute art, pointing to DiCorcia’s reputation and the creative process the photographer used, along with the fact the photos weren’t used to advertise anything but the exhibition itself. The court also found that the First Amendment protects the use of someone’s images in ways that they may not approve of, or even find religiously or spiritually offensive. This is “the price every person must be prepared to pay for in a society in which information and opinion flow freely,” the court noted.
In an age of street photography, when everyone is armed with a camera to take photos and social media accounts to distribute them, there is a growing acceptance that walking outside may mean ending up on someone’s Instagram, if not in a famous photograph. If by some happenstance your face does wind up on the walls of the MoMA in a work of fine art and you’d rather it not, there’s very little you can do. But, hey, at least that’s one thing the average Joe has in common with the most famous celebrity.
Isaac Kaplan is an Associate Editor at Artsy.

How Artwork Gets into Movies




Art Market
How Artwork Gets into Movies
Set for Nip/Tuck. Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
Set for Nip/Tuck. Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
At first glance, the geometric red and orange painting hanging behind Reese Witherspoon in a scene from the 2017 romantic comedy Home Again could pass as an authentic Mark Rothko. The color blocks are roughly similar to the great Abstract Expressionist’s signature style. And a pricey Rothko is certainly a plausible possession for Witherspoon’s character, who lives in the sprawling Hollywood home of her fictitious Oscar-winning film director father.  
But far from being a multi-million dollar Rothko, the Home Again artwork was created by Catherine Booker Jones, an Alabama-based painter whose work caught director Hallie Meyers-Shyer’s attention on a Pinterest board.
Even as computer-generated images allow Hollywood directors to create increasingly dazzling spectacles for their films, the fundamental task of decorating a set still requires working with real artists and deftly navigating decades-old copyright laws. For any project, finding period-appropriate artwork with legal clearance to appear on screen can be a real challenge. That’s why, when it came to putting art on the silver screen for the Meyers-Shyer rom-com, it made more sense to hang a commissioned work by Jones reminiscent of Rothko than a real original.
“Art is one of the hardest parts of what we do for film,” says Ellen Brill, an eight-time Emmy nominated set decorator who designed Home Again. “It really is.”
Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
Set for Home Again. Courtesy of O. Retentoff.
Set for Home Again. Courtesy of O. Retentoff.
Under the Copyright Term Extension Act of 1998 (an extension of the Copyright Act of 1976), artworks generally enter the public domain 70 years after an artist’s death. Until that time, artists or their estates retain the rights to the display and use of their work, and must clear any appearance in a film (artists generally retain their rights even if a specific work is actually owned by someone else).
Even when an artist’s work is slated to enter the public domain, an artist’s estate, a museum, a photographer, or another entity may retain rights to the images, making the clearance-getting process murky and tiresome. This makes it difficult to use works by modern masters such as Rothko (who died in 1970), for example.
The clearance process is so arduous, in fact, that productions usually have a person devoted to the job: a clearance coordinator. Some projects even require an entire legal department. Clearance coordinators are responsible for obtaining legal permission to use a range of components—from book titles to street addresses, billboard designs, names, and artwork.
When getting clearance for artwork to appear on screen, the coordinator often requests permission from multiple entities, such as an artist’s estate and a museum. Given the tangled nature of copyright and the potential for copyright infringement lawsuits, “you have to cover your bases across the board,” says Rose Lagacé, a Toronto-based production designer who has worked on the television series Covert Affairs and films on Netflix and Bravo.
Set for Nip/Tuck. Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
Set for Nip/Tuck. Courtesy of Ellen Brill.
Set decorators have become adept at maneuvering around the system. Unless a work by a canonical artist is expressly scripted (as in the case of a Jasper Johns American flag painting that Lagacé recalls was specified for Covert Affairs), they often turn to local and emerging artists who are easier to work with, rather than jump through the legal hoops required to use a work by a famous artist.
Cost is one factor in avoiding works by established masters, since clearance fees can be high. “If I work with a local artist or someone I find and contact online, I can make a deal with them and say, ‘Hey, I saw your art, I’d love to use it in this project, here’s X amount of money—can I rent three pieces from you and hold them for two weeks, or can you send me files?’” explains set decorator Lydia Marks, who has designed sets for films such as The Devil Wears Prada, Sex and the City (1 and 2), and Broken Flowers. “That’s easier than trying to track down something that exists somewhere that you have to backtrack on and go through a clearance process.”
For the 2008 film Synecdoche, New York, Marks commissioned Alex Kanevsky to paint the work supposedly created by Catherine Keener’s character. When designing a room required to have 27 portraits for the television series American Horror Story, Brill commissioned a Florida-based painter to create five of them.
Set directors sometimes also tap local artists to paint in the style of more art historically recognizable masterpieces, such as in Home Again. Set decorators must make sure the work is reminiscent enough without qualifying, legally, as copyright infringement.
“If you can’t [afford to use fine art], you have to figure out other ways to make it look like you’re using real, good stuff,” Brill says. “A lot of times you can have your scenic painter paint something ‘in the style of’, and if it’s different, then you can get away with it.”
Set for Home Again. Courtesy of O. Retentoff.
Set for Home Again. Courtesy of O. Retentoff.
In cases where time is a factor, though, and no specific artworks have been scripted, set decorators may opt to use commercial companies that offer pre-cleared material for film and TV productions. When Spanish production designer Sonia Aranzabal, who has worked on The Bourne Ultimatum and Broken Embraces, recently had two days to design the set for a commercial that would be broadcast across Europe and the Middle East, she turned to hassle-free Cuadros Rent gallery in Madrid.
Such galleries exist across the globe, and unsurprisingly, there are many in Los Angeles. Using works in these galleries comes with no litigation risk. But designers are liable to see their selections star elsewhere on screen. “Easily, you could see a piece on one show, and then, a week later you can see it on the wall in someone else’s apartment,” Brill explains. “So that’s kind of a reason not to want to do that.”
After all, we expect film and television to provide singular stories full of glitzy stars, extraordinary situations, and dazzling artwork most of us could never afford. Seeing the same piece of art in two totally separate shows pierces the illusion. So while clearance coordinating isn’t a job characters often have on the silver screen, that hard work off-screen makes the magic feel more real.
Karen Chernick