Monday, January 1, 2018

Top Art News Stories of 2017—Part 2




News
The Top Art News Stories of 2017—Part 2
Here’s part two of the top 20 art world news stories from this year, arranged in chronological order.

11  Several former top South Korean government officials received prison time for their roles in blacklisting thousands of artists in the country.

A court handed down stiff sentences on July 27th to several prominent political figures in South Korea who were accused of abuse of power and perjury, among other charges, the New York Times reported. The accused were top members of the administration of ousted South Korean president Park Geun-hye, who was removed from office by the country’s constitutional court for corruption in March. They faced charges for their role in secretly ordering the blacklist of thousands of artists because of their politics, barring them receiving government funding or support. News of the blacklist first surfaced last year, prompting widespread outrage in South Korea. Among the six officials sentenced is Kim Ki-choon, former chief of staff to President Park Geun-hye, who received three years after being convicted for creating the blacklist, then lying about his role before South Korea’s parliament. Kim Jong-deok, a former culture minister, was sentenced to two years for similar charges.

12  The Guggenheim pulled three artworks featuring live animals from an exhibition amid allegations that the works contained animal cruelty.

The Guggenheim removed two videos and one sculpture from “Art and China after 1989: Theater of the World” on September 25th, citing unspecified but “explicit and repeated threats of violence” as the reason. The exhibition opened without the three works on October 6th. Controversy around the exhibition erupted in late September and initially centered on Dogs That Cannot Touch Each Other (2003), a video work by artists Sun Yuan and Peng Yu that shows restrained dogs on treadmills running in an attempt to fight one another. The work quickly drew criticism, including a petition calling for “cruelty-free” exhibitions at the museum, which gained 600,000 signatures in five days. Two other works, A Case Study of Transference (1994) by Xu Bing, a video showing live pigs mating, and Theater of the World by Huang Yong Ping, the exhibition’s titular work of live insects and reptiles devouring each other, were also not shown. While animal rights activists and some art historians applauded the move, critics charged that the museum had censored the works. “As an arts institution committed to presenting a multiplicity of voices, we are dismayed that we must withhold works of art,” the museum said in a statement. “Freedom of expression has always been and will remain a paramount value of the Guggenheim.”

13  The United States withdrew from UNESCO, the United Nations cultural organization.

The U.S. Department of State cited “the need for fundamental reform” and “continuing anti-Israel bias” at UNESCO, along with “concerns with mounting arrears” owed by the U.S. when the move was announced on October 12th. The tangible financial and legal impact of leaving UNESCO, experts say, are few. The U.S. had its UNESCO voting rights suspended in 2013, after two years of refusing to pay dues, following the acceptance of Palestine into the cultural organization as a full member in 2011. The withdrawal halts the increase in owed dues that the U.S. would have to pay if it wished to reenter UNESCO at any point in the future. America’s annual contributions amounted to, then, around $80 million, or 22 percent of UNESCO’s budget, and the U.S. owes in the region of $550 million to the organization. Audrey Azoulay, who was elected as UNESCO’s director-general just one day after the U.S. announced its withdrawal, has said that U.S.’s departure is “not the beginning and end” of the agency.

14  Beatrix Ruf resigned as director of Amsterdam’s influential Stedelijk Museum amid allegations of conflicts of interest.

The allegations stemmed from Ruf’s operation of a private art advisory service while serving as director, and the terms attached to a major donation to the institution last year. Ruf’s resignation came after a pair of investigations were published by the Dutch daily NRC Handelsblad. One of the reports revealed that Ruf earned €437,306 in 2015 from her private art advisory company, Currentmatters. The Stedelijk’s annual report from the same year—which specifically provides a space for the museum to disclose its director’s activities outside of her employment there—includes no reference to Currentmatters (which is registered in Switzerland), nor to any income she derived from it. A statement posted on the museum’s website on October 17th cites “speculations in the media over the past weeks that may have an impact on [our] reputation” as the reason for Ruf’s departure. Ruf called the allegations a “misunderstanding,” in a November interview with the New York Times, telling the paper that she “reported everything in good faith” to the Stedelijk Museum and that the payment to Currentmatters was mainly for services rendered prior to her assuming the role of artistic director. Ruf is frequently cited as among the contemporary art world’s most influential players, and served as the director of the Kunsthalle Zürich for 12 years before taking up her post at the Stedelijk in 2014.

15  Several prominent art world figures—including Artforum publisher Knight Landesman and artist Chuck Close—were accused of sexual misconduct.

Landesman, the longtime co-publisher of Artforum, resigned on October 25th following allegations of sexual harassment first reported by Rachel Corbett in artnet News. The same day, Amanda Schmitt, a former employee of Artforum, sued both the publication and Landesman for defamation and retaliation, among other allegations, asserting that she was sexually harassed both during and after her time at the publication. Both Landesman and Artforum each moved to dismiss the lawsuit in December. In October, the publication vowed to “transform Artforum into a place of transparency, equity, and with zero tolerance for sexual harassment of any kind.” Landesman is one of several high-profile men in the artworld to be accused of sexual misconduct in the wake of the Harvey Weinstein scandal, including former Jewish Museum deputy director Jens Hoffmann and Benjamin Genocchio, who was removed as executive director of the Armory Show following allegations made against him in the New York Times. Artist Chuck Close was accused of sexual misconduct by multiple women in December, including one who said he had invited her to pose for him before asking her to strip naked and then made lewd comments about her vagina. Close denied the specific comments, but apologized to any he made feel uncomfortable. “Last time I looked, discomfort was not a major offense,” he told the New York Times.

16  Beijing’s Ullens Center for Contemporary Art was purchased by a Chinese investment group, securing the 798 Art District landmark’s future.

Art collector Guy Ullens, who co-founded and financially supported the Ullens Center for Contemporary Art (UCCA), put the institution up for sale in 2016. It spent an uncertain year on the market before selling for an undisclosed amount to the investor group in October. Previously a private company, the UCCA will now operate as a non-profit and tax-exempt foundation. Director of UCCA, Philip Tinari, has said he expects the new status as a foundation will allow the institution to raise additional funding and improve exhibitions and visitor traffic. He also affirmed that the museum has received assurance that it would remain in the 798 Art District for the long term. “Our mission continues to be a desire to put Chinese art in a global context, to provoke and stimulate a discussion about a vital part of art history,” he told the South China Morning Post. Ullens’s decision to sell the museum raised questions about the sustainability of China’s private museums and art centers, institutions that are individually owned and dependent on those benefactors for funding. The center is slated to soon undergo renovations, reopening in 2018 with a solo show of artist Xu Bing.

17  Documenta 14 ran a major €5.4 million ($6.3 million) budget deficit.

Curated by Adam Szymczyk, the fourteenth edition of Documenta ran up a deficit due in large part to Szymczyk’s decision to host the quinquennial art exhibition in Athens, Greece, in addition to the event’s regular location of Kassel, Germany, according to the findings of an independent auditor. The deficit prompted the resignation of Annette Kulenkampff, the CEO of Documenta’s parent company, on November 27th, artnet News reported, along with criticism of Szymczyk’s handling of the event’s financials. But the curator and his team have remained defiant since news of the deficit was first reported by German daily HNA in September, arguing that all of the Documenta stakeholders approved of the dual-venue format, and that “the money flowing into the city through the making of Documenta greatly exceeds the amount the city and region spend on the exhibition.” Documenta’s artists have come out in support of their curator, penning twoopen letters in defense of the show. Despite initial concerns that the cost overrun could endanger future editions, officials confirmed that Documenta’s 15th edition will run from June 18th to September 25th, 2022 in Kassel, The Art Newspaper reported.

18  Abu Dhabi acquired Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi (c. 1500) for a record-smashing $450 million.

The work sold after 19 minutes of bidding at Christie’s post-war and contemporary sale on November 15th. The final $450 million price, including fees, is the most ever paid for a work of art, well above the rumored $300 million that billionaire hedge fund manager Ken Griffin paid for Willem de Kooning’s Interchange (1955) in 2015. The identity of the buyer of the Leonardo remained a mystery at the time, but an article in the Wall Street Journal in early December identified a little-known Saudi Arabian prince, operating as a proxy for the country’s crown prince Mohammed Bin Salman, as the bidder. Saudi authorities quickly denied that the crown prince had been behind the work’s purchase, and Christie’s released a statement confirming that the work was acquired by Abu Dhabi’s Department of Culture and Tourism for the Louvre Abu Dhabi, which opened to the public on November 11th. One person “briefed on the deal” told the Financial Times that the Saudi government had purchased the work for the United Arab Emirates, the federation that includes Abu Dhabi, saying, “It is supposed to be a state to state gift, like when France gave the Statue of Liberty to the US.”

19  A tomb in Jerusalem was built by ancient Romans to mark the burial place of Jesus Christ, research suggests.

Researchers tested mortar found inside the purported tomb of Christ, which is located within Jerusalem’s Church of the Holy Sepulchre, to determine if its age matches historical accounts of the site. Some scholars had questioned whether the church—which has been destroyed, damaged, and rebuilt several times over thousands of years—actually marks the site that ancient Romans (dispatched to the region by Emperor Constantine), identified as Christ’s burial place in around 326 A.D., according to historical records. Previously, the oldest materials in the Church have been dated to the much later Crusader period. But new research released on November 28th by a team from the National Technical University of Athens found that the mortar used within the tomb, opened in October of 2016 for the first time in centuries, does indeed date back to roughly 345 AD, suggesting that it is the tomb identified by ancient Romans. “While it is archaeologically impossible to say that the tomb is the burial site of an individual Jew known as Jesus of Nazareth,” wrote National Geographic, “new dating results put the original construction of today’s tomb complex securely in the time of Constantine.”

20  British artist Lubaina Himid became the first woman of color and the oldest artist ever to win the Turner Prize, Britain’s most prestigious art award.

Himid was presented with the award on December 5th at a ceremony held in the northern English city of Hull, where her work is on view until January 7th in an exhibition dedicated to artists shortlisted for the prize. The 63-year-old Zanzibar-born artist—whose work deals with race and black identity—grew up in London and lives in the northern city of Preston. In her acceptance speech, broadcast live on BBC News, Himid thanked the Turner Prize jury and her supporters. “To the people who have stopped me in the streets of Preston and Hull to wish me luck—thank you, it worked,” she said. Himid also thanked the art historians who wrote about her practice in what she called the “wilderness years.” Administered by London’s Tate, the Turner Prize was founded in 1984 and “aims to promote public debate around new developments in contemporary British art” with the annual £25,000 award going to a British artist deemed to have an “outstanding exhibition or other presentation” in a given year.
Artsy Editors
Header image by Eduardo Munoz/Getty Images.


Lawsuits That Could Reshape the Art World





Art Market
5 Lawsuits That Could Reshape the Art World in 2018
While 2018 will surely spark a whole new slate of lawsuits, some of the the new year’s most significant art-related cases are already pending. Here are five lawsuits dealing with everything from free speech to copyright infringement that we will be keeping an eye on.

Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission

Filed July 2012

Dave Mullins and Charlie Craig in 2012. Photo by Kathryn Scott Osler/The Denver Post, via Getty Images.
Dave Mullins and Charlie Craig in 2012. Photo by Kathryn Scott Osler/The Denver Post, via Getty Images.
On December 5th of this year, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. Among the questions raised by the case: Are cakes artworks? The query is an unexpected one to find at the heart of a major anti-discrimination lawsuit that pits a gay couple against the religious baker who refused to create a cake for their wedding, asserting it would violate his religious beliefs. In response, the couple, Charlie Craig and David Mullins, sued “cake artist” Jack Phillips, who runs a small bakery in Colorado called Masterpiece Cakeshop.
Craig and Mullins sued in 2012 and prevailed at the local and appellate level. But Phillips appealed, and now the Supreme Court has heard the case. The major issue at the heart of the lawsuit is the constitutionality of a Colorado law that bars business owners from discriminating against customers because of their race, creed, national origin, and sexual orientation, among other aspects of their identity. Phillips has argued that the law violates his first amendment rights by compelling him to “speak” by producing artworks (his cakes). In his brief to the Supreme Court, which compares cake art to the works of Alexander Calder and other artists, Phillips argues that the law regulates speech and as such needs to be subject to stricter court scrutiny that would see it ruled unconstitutional. The ACLU, which is representing Craig and Mullins, charge that the law does not regulate speech but simply mandates that businesses must treat customers equally, whatever product they’re selling.  

Why it Matters:

The Colorado statute is similar to many anti-discrimination laws in states across the country, and the Supreme Court’s ruling in this case will impact those laws outside of Colorado as well. Effectively, should Phillips win, businesses, under the guise of artistic expression, could refuse to serve those in the LGBTQ community by arguing that service violates their religious beliefs. The argument advanced by Phillips is “an argument that the Constitution protects discrimination,” Louise Melling, deputy legal director for the ACLU, told Artsy.

Graham v. Prince et al

Filed December 2015

Absolutely no one will be shocked to find appropriation artist Richard Prince on this list. Prince is the king of copyright infringement cases. He’s been sued numerous times for using artworks created by others in his own work without permission or payment. He often wins these cases by asserting fair use—that is, his use of artwork created by others falls under an exception to copyright law reserved for the original transformative use of copyrighted works (though courts weigh other factors in determining fair use as well).
Prince broadened fair use in 2013 with Cariou v. Prince after an appellate court found that for appropriation to qualify as fair use it need only imbue the original work with some new meaning or message—even if that is intangible.
In the 2015 case Graham v. Prince et al, photographer Donald Graham sued Prince and his dealer, Larry Gagosian, after Graham’s 1996 photograph Rastafarian Smoking a Joint appeared in a work in Prince’s Instagram series exhibited at Gagosian gallery in 2014. Prince moved to dismiss the case, asserting fair use, but a judge shot down that motion in July 2017. Though a motion to dismiss comes with a high legal bar (the facts are interpreted in a way most favorable to Graham), the ruling “wasn’t good for Prince,” writesBill Donahue at Law360.

Why it matters:

Even after the 2013 case, the judge in Graham v. Prince found Prince’s total and full use of Graham’s image—without any alteration beyond adding some Instagram comments—does not lend itself to a clear-cut fair use argument. The case will now proceed to trial. If Prince loses (a big if) and the ruling is upheld on appeal (an even bigger if) the resulting precedent could reign in the broader fair use interpretation afforded to artists by the earlier ruling.

Berkshire Museum Lawsuits

Filed October 20, 2017 and October 26, 2017

Protestors at the Berkshire Museum in August. Photo by Gillian Jones for the Berkshire Eagle.
Protestors at the Berkshire Museum in August. Photo by Gillian Jones for the Berkshire Eagle.
You have to wonder how many members of the artworld could point to Pittsfield, Massachusetts on a map before the Berkshire Museum announced in July that it would be auctioning 40 artworks from its permanent collection. The institution planned to use the estimated $60 million raised from the sale at Sotheby’s to fund renovations and boost the endowment—a clear-cut violation of industry guidelines around deaccessioning.
The sale brought condemnation from across the artworld, with the American Alliance of Museums and the Association of Art Museum Directors calling for a halt to the sale that would almost certainly see works by Norman Rockwell, Alexander Calder, and the other greats slated to be sold leave the public trust and enter private collections. Other observers, including the editorial board of the Boston Globe, argued the sale should be allowed to go ahead. For its part, the museum asserted it needed the funds to plug a financial hole and that it was pivoting away from fine art—recasting itself as a science and technology focused institution.
The lawsuits came flying. A group of Rockwell descendants sued to halt the sale, as did members of the museum, alleging the trustees were violating their fiduciary duty by auctioning the work. Those suits were dismissed on November 7th with a judge finding the plaintiffs didn’t have standing to bring the case. (The suit brought by the Berkshire Museum members has since been appealed.) A last minute intervention from the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office (AGO) staved off the sale of the works, with an appellate justice ruling on November 10th that the Sotheby’s auction could not proceed so the suit could be adjudicated. A wide-reaching investigation into the museum by the AGO is ongoing.

Why it Matters:

However the suit ultimately turns out, its impact on the museum community is already massive. If the Berkshire Museum is allowed to sell, it could make it more difficult to prevent other museums from selling works in their collections to cover operating costs in the future. But even if the museum does win, the protracted, bitter, public, and ultimately embarrassing lawsuits—including the intervention of the AGO—means that institutions from Maine to California will think of what happened in Pittsfield before ever deaccessioning an artwork in violation of industry guidelines in the future.

The Guelph Treasure Case

Filed February 2015

The Guelph Treasure also deals with Nazi restitution, but the case is in far more nascent stages. The suit centers around the Guelph Treasure, named after the princely German House of Guelph, which was sold by a group of German-Jewish dealers in the lead up to World War II. A group of the dealers’ heirs—two of whom live in the United States (the third in London)—sued in an American court for the restitution of the works, arguing the sale was coerced by the Nazis. Germany moved to dismiss the case, arguing that as a sovereign state it is not subject to the jurisdiction of U.S. courts. But a district court disagreed, ruling in March that Germany would have to answer the claims. The case marks the first time Germany has had to face a restitution lawsuit in a U.S. court.

Why it Matters:

The appeals court ruling in the Guelph Treasure case will likely have broader legal significance on the scope of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA), which prevents foreign governments from being used in U.S. Court. Over the past few years courts have broadened an exception to FSIA, known as the expropriation exception, finding that the exception applies if property, such as an artwork, was forcibly taken “in violation of international law” either as part of a genocide or in the lead up to a genocide. If the appellate court tosses out the Guelph Treasure case and narrows the applicability of the exception to FSIA, it would deal a serious blow to those looking to reclaim Nazi-looted art from state owned art in foreign countries.

Von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum

Filed May 2007

Lucas Cranach the Elder, Adam and Eve, circa 1530. Image via Wikimedia Commons.
Lucas Cranach the Elder, Adam and Eve, circa 1530. Image via Wikimedia Commons.
Von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum is a long-running legal battle. In 2007, Marei von Saher sued the Norton Simon Museum in Pasadena, California, seeking the return of two works by Lucas Cranach the Elder held in the museum’s collection but which originally belonged to her father-in-law, Jewish art dealer Jacques Goudstikker. He was forced to sell the pieces before fleeing Germany in 1940. While both sides agree the paintings were looted by Nazis, Norton Simon has consistently argued that it holds legal title to the work.

The case has dragged on for years. Just weeks before a trial was supposed to finally begin in 2016, the judge hearing the case ruled that the Norton Simon Museum could keep the paintings in a move that surprised court observers. Von Saher appealed the ruling. The appellate court could finally put an end to this long running saga by either upholding the ruling of the lower court, or reversing it and finding in favor of von Saher without any trial; or it could kick the case back to a lower court and argue the trial needs to proceed.

Why it Matters:

The facts in the von Saher case are relatively specific (the case turns on the reading of certain post-war Dutch laws, for reasons you can read about here), meaning whatever decision the appellate court does reach won’t have broad legal ramifications. But given the publicity around the case, a triumph by von Saher could encourage more heirs to come forward with fresh restitution suits, with a loss having the opposite effect.
Isaac Kaplan is an Associate Editor at Artsy.