Elizabeth Maynard
In a news cycle that cultivates short attention spans, it is alarming how quickly ecological and human rights violations are buried, and sometimes actively suppressed, in the ever-scrolling news feed along with the long history of such events.
When he was an undergraduate, the artist Daniel Heyman recalls, he would study in Dartmouth College’s library beneath José Clemente Orozco’s bold and caustic mural, The Epic of American Civilization (1932-34), an alternately ironic and horrifying depiction of American history. That narrative is woven through many of Heyman’s works, which are currently on view at Cade Tompkins Projects in Daniel Heyman: Dartmouth Collection and Native Impressions. The exhibition features works he produced during his 2013 tenure as Artist in Residence at Dartmouth College, as well as a collaboration with printmaker Lucy Ganje called In Our Own Words: Native Impressions 2015 – 2016,
The Dartmouth Collection includes a variety of mixed-media works produced while in residence at Dartmouth, including studies of Orozco’s mural. It is worth noting that Orozco was the college’s second artist-in-residence after the program began in 1932, and that Dartmouth was founded with the specific aim of educating and converting Native American men.
Heyman’s vibrant paintings are filled with recurring images: delicate cranes sourced from Japanese textile and paper design, luscious multi-colored flowers in full bloom, fields of meticulously painted swirls evoking hand-made marbled paper, and a smiling gibbon. However, both Heart Fist (2013) and To Ride the Son (2013) include a motif based on the descriptions of torture he recounted in a series of works called the Abu Ghraib Detainee Interview Project (2006-07), while observing interviews between former prisoners and American lawyers in Amman and Istanbul. In the 2013 paintings, one hooded figure slumps on top of another on all fours.
In The Body in Pain, Elaine Scarry argues that pain is marked by its inherent inexpressibility and that torture is a structure of unmaking the world of its victim through the very unsharability of their experience. Indeed, we rely on referential descriptors when trying to communicate our pain: it feels as if … Part of what Heyman’s paintings accomplish is to point to the instability of language and the sign, and how easily communication is confounded, whether intentionally or through the very impossibility of conveyance.
Even so, Heyman’s work has long reckoned with the significance of voice even in the face of this obstruction. His Abu Ghraib Detainee Interview Project, features portraits of Iraqi detainees surrounded by swirling fragments of their stories, painted quickly so that he would complete the work by the end of the interview. In these works, Heyman aimed for as direct a representation as possible, as if he were attempting to resist the manipulation of these stories for the purposes of others.
Together, the sheets hint at a more complete possibility of portraiture — subjects depicted both visually and “in their own words,” a distinct counterpoint to the current silencing of resistance actions, and a poignant response to the 19th-century American legacy of depictions of native peoples, such as George Catlin’s ethnographic portraiture and Frederic Remington’s fantasies of the “Old West.” (Yale University’s Beinecke Library has purchased an edition of Heyman’s prints to act in dialogue with their holding of Catlin’s North American Indian Portfolio, 1844.)
In kind, Ganje’s compositions are bold and engaging, both obscuring and highlighting words that evoke the recurrent themes of religious, political, and ecological colonization, as well as the pride and difficulty of “growing up on the rez.” The narratives include past stories of forced conversion and isolation, hard labor conditions, but also contemporary outrage over environmental abuse and social injustice — “oil” and “water” emerge throughout the broadsheets, pointing to the current resistance by Standing Rock Sioux (one of the nations represented in the portrait series) against the Dakota Access Pipeline.
While paintings like Catlin’s and Remington’s suppose an image of the Native as disappearing or disappeared, just as contemporary news coverage would have us shift to the spectacle of the election, Heyman and Ganje’s portraits insist on confronting the contemporary experience of American Indians through the individual voice, all the while acknowledging the profound difficulties of performing, recording, and interpreting oral histories of people historically and continually denied a voice. Heyman, driven by conviction, grapples with the intrinsic complications of articulating suffering and stories untold. There are no easy answers here, but there is a sense of what’s needed to redress victimization and violence. In Heyman and Ganje’s print, “It Was Such A Joy: Portrait of Leigh Jeanotte,” bold pink letters proclaim, “A CHANCE, A CHANCE, A VOICE, A VOICE.”
Daniel Heyman: Dartmouth Collection and Native Impressions continues at Cade Tompkins Projects (198 Hope St, Providence, Rhode Island) through today.
No comments:
Post a Comment